Midea MRT18D1B vs Midea HD-423ST-BKS
Two of the full-size refrigerators in our best full-size refrigerators comparison, lined up spec by spec. Every figure comes from the manufacturer pages linked below, and the scores use the same published formula as the full ranking.
Affiliate disclosure: We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never affects our rankings, which come from the published scoring formula. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.
Best for: Official 10% less energy than the U.S. federal standard, 18.2 cu ft total volume, 369 kWh/year
Check price at AmazonBest for: Official 10% less energy than the U.S. federal standard, 11.5 cu ft total volume, 311 kWh/year
Check price at AmazonSpec-by-spec comparison
Green marks the better published figure. "Not listed" means the manufacturer doesn't publish it.
| Spec | Midea MRT18D1B | Midea HD-423ST-BKS | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Percent less energy than U.S. federal standardOfficial ENERGY STAR figure for how much less annual energy the model uses than the U.S. federal standard for its product class. Higher is better. A missing value takes the category minimum. | 10 % | 10 % | 36% |
| Certified total volumeOfficial ENERGY STAR certified total volume in cubic feet. A larger cabinet is not automatically the right refrigerator for a small kitchen. Missing values take the category minimum. | 18.2 cu ft | 11.5 cu ft | 28% |
| Annual energy useOfficial ENERGY STAR annual energy use in kilowatt-hours per year. Lower is better. Because a larger cabinet often uses more energy, this field is scored alongside volume and the percent-better figure. Missing values take the category minimum (the highest energy use in the set). | 369 kWh/year | 311 kWh/year | 22% |
| Ice makerYes when the official ENERGY STAR record lists an ice maker. Unstated counts as no. | No | No | 14% |
| Percent less energy use than U.S. federal standard (ENERGY STAR) | 10% | 10% | info |
| Annual energy use (ENERGY STAR) | 369 kWh/year | 311 kWh/year | info |
| Certified total volume (ENERGY STAR) | 18.2 cu ft | 11.5 cu ft | info |
| Annual energy use per cubic foot (computed) | 20.3 kWh/year per cubic foot, computed as certified annual energy use ÷ certified total volume | 27.0 kWh/year per cubic foot, computed as certified annual energy use ÷ certified total volume | info |
| U.S. federal standard energy use (ENERGY STAR) | 412 kWh/year | 346 kWh/year | info |
| Adjusted volume (ENERGY STAR) | 22.1 cu ft | 13.9 cu ft | info |
| Type (ENERGY STAR) | Top Freezer | Top Freezer | info |
| Product class (ENERGY STAR) | 3 - Refrigerator-freezers - automatic defrost with top-mounted freezer without an automatic ice maker | 3 - Refrigerator-freezers - automatic defrost with top-mounted freezer without an automatic ice maker | info |
| Defrost type (ENERGY STAR) | Automatic | Automatic | info |
| Ice maker (ENERGY STAR) | No | No | info |
| Counter depth (ENERGY STAR) | No | No | info |
| Thru-the-door dispenser (ENERGY STAR) | No | No | info |
| Connected functionality (ENERGY STAR) | No | No | info |
| Dimensions (ENERGY STAR) | 66.6 × 29.7 in (H × W) | 59.8 × 25 in (H × W) | info |
| Refrigerant (ENERGY STAR) | R-600a | Not listed | info |
| Meets ENERGY STAR Most Efficient 2025 criteria | Yes | Yes | info |
| Certified model number | MRT18D1B** | HD-423ST-BKS | info |
| Official brand name on the ENERGY STAR record | Midea | Midea | info |
| Related official records with the same certified ratings | Same official certified ratings also appear on Midea MRT18D2B; Midea MRT18D4B. We keep one product page for this rating set so color, finish or brand rebadges are not given separate nearly identical pages. | Same official certified ratings also appear on Elisii DERTM1151; Elisii DERTM115WW1; Smad DDT-423WMU (U); Vissani MDTF12. We keep one product page for this rating set so color, finish or brand rebadges are not given separate nearly identical pages. | info |
| CrispPick score | 3.7/10 | 3.0/10 | 100% |
Where each one comes out ahead
Midea MRT18D1B
Better published figure on: Certified total volume.
What we like
- Official record meets ENERGY STAR Most Efficient 2025 criteria
Watch out for
- ENERGY STAR does not list an ice maker on this record
Midea HD-423ST-BKS
Better published figure on: Annual energy use.
What we like
- Official record meets ENERGY STAR Most Efficient 2025 criteria
Watch out for
- ENERGY STAR does not list an ice maker on this record
Verdict
Both official ENERGY STAR records list these models as Top Freezer. The Midea HD-423ST-BKS record lists 10% less energy than the U.S. federal standard, 11.5 cu ft total volume and 311 kWh/year. The Midea MRT18D1B record lists 10% less energy than the U.S. federal standard, 18.2 cu ft total volume and 369 kWh/year. ENERGY STAR does not list an ice maker on either record.
- Midea MRT18D1B: ENERGY STAR Product Finder: MRT18D1B
- Midea MRT18D1B: ENERGY STAR certified residential refrigerators dataset
- Midea HD-423ST-BKS: ENERGY STAR Product Finder: HD-423ST-BKS
- Midea HD-423ST-BKS: ENERGY STAR certified residential refrigerators dataset